Mortality, wastage, and lifetime productivity of Bos indicus cows under extensive grazing in northern Australia. 3. Comparison of culling strategies

Abstract

Strategies for culling on reproductive outcome were evaluated for 2 herds at Swan's Lagoon in the northern speargrass region and 1 herd at Kidman Springs in the semi-arid tropics by editing the records from actual culling to simulate more stringent culling policies. The greatest impact was for young cows, with 13.6 and 27.5% of 2-year-old cows in the 2 herds at Swan's Lagoon failing to rear a calf, and 39.8% at Kidman Springs failing to rear a calf. The corresponding failure rates as 3-year-old cows were 48.1, 54.9, and 80.2%, respectively. Culling for 2 consecutive reproductive failures at Kidman Springs resulted in cumulative wastage of cows >60% by 4 years of age. Other strategies based on 1 or 2 failures had cumulative wastage 80% by 5 years of age and were too severe to be sustained in the harsh environment at Kidman Springs, with low productivity. At Swan's Lagoon, heifer replacement rates were 17.5-22.2% for strategies based on 2 failures and averaged 37.3% for a single reproductive failure but were 28.7% when failure as a 3-year-old was not penalised. At Kidman Springs, heifer replacement rates were 29.3% for 2 consecutive reproductive failures and reduced to 21.3% when 2-year-olds were retained but were very high (33.7-56.7%) for stricter culling strategies. With current branding rates, only culling on 2 reproductive failures in the speargrass region and extremely limited culling on 3 failures in the semi-arid tropics can be recommended as practical options. The lifetime number of calves reared from cows up to 10 years of age at Swan's Lagoon averaged 3.1 when culling was based on 2 failures and 2.2 for culling on a single failure; this increased to 2.8 calves reared when the strategy was relaxed for 3-year-olds. At Kidman Springs the number of calves reared was 2.3 with culling on 2 consecutive reproductive failures but was closer to the actual level at 2.9 when 2-year-old cows were not culled for reproductive failure.